Sunday, 15 May 2016

Residential versus Commercial Property

 Some observers think that successful property investors start off buying residential properties, but end up migrating to commercial property. The implication is that without making this transition, it is difficult to become fabulously wealthy. Is this necessarily so?

High profile investors tend indeed to be commercial property investors. However, this correlation need not be because successful investors favor commercial property. Rather, it could be that it is the commercial properties themselves that give these investors the high profile. The sale of a substantial landmark building is considered newsworthy; the sale of a portfolio of 80 houses usually doesn't get a mention.
Whether or not to migrate to commercial property may well be one of the biggest strategic decisions you will make in your property investment career.
As with any strategic decision, there are pros and cons. Let's review some of the main considerations.
Firstly, the capital required to get into residential property is generally a lot less than that required to get into commercial property. Herein lies the main appeal of dwellings to investors just starting out. Secondly, banks tend to offer a much higher gearing ration on residential loans compared with commercial loans (typically 80% versus 60%). Once again, this makes residential properties seem much more appealing.
Thirdly, the market for residential space is a lot more fluid and dynamic than that for commercial space. What this means is that it is generally a lot easier to find a tenant for a vacant house than a vacant commercial premise. And if your house has been vacant for more than a few weeks, you have only one problem. . . It is not that the wallpaper in the hall has the wrong color, or that the dining room is facing the wrong way. It is simply that the rent is too high: drop it by $100 or $200 per month and you will soon find a tenant.
By contrast, if your commercial property is vacant, dropping the rent by even 50% may still not lure a tenant. Commercial tenants tend to have specific needs, so that their premises are very specialized (consider the needs of a bakery versus say a retail store or a warehouse). Consequently, while your residential property should not be vacant for more than a few weeks at a time, it is not uncommon for commercial properties to be vacant for months or even years at a time. Having the mental fortitude, not to mention cashflow, to sustain such a long vacancy is crucial to surviving as a commercial landlord.
That brings us to the fourth point. When looking at a residential property, it is easy to figure out if "everything is there". Most people would notice the absence of a bathroom, kitchen, or front door. However, in looking at commercial property, many people feel they are outside of the comfort zone, since they don't know what to look for. They haven't got a clue whether something vital is missing.
Finally, whatever the state of the economy, everyone has to live somewhere. Thus, in a depressed economy, even though rentals may drop, the total number of occupied homes will not fall much (there will be a slight drop as extended families consolidate into fewer homes). However, in the same depressed economy, many commercial premises may end up being vacant (through leases not being renewed or through default). To that extent, residential property is much safer.
Of course if these were the only considerations, then everyone would only invest in residential properties. Clearly commercial properties must have some advantages of their own.
One fundamental difference is that with residential properties you tend to deal with people, whereas with commercial you tend to deal with contracts. Since contracts are much easier to understand than people, it is simpler to manage commercial properties.
Furthermore, the law makes managing residential properties difficult. For instance, a tenant can, in many jurisdictions, be in default for many weeks before you can start to take any kind of action, by which time the tenant could be anywhere. By contrast, if a commercial tenant is in default by even a couple of days, then you may resort to remedies as spelled out in the lease contract. These remedies may include charging penalty interest at a rate specified in the lease, right through to "distraining" for rent. This means that you can secure the premises by changing the locks, and sell the tenant's chattels (under strict conditions) to recover the rent owed. Try doing that with residential property!
Not only are commercial tenants aware of these "rules" but they also tend to derive their incomes from the commercial premises, so that they have a vested interest in keeping the premises looking good. Typically, lease contracts require the tenants to look after internal maintenance of the premises. This equates to no phone calls for leaking taps.
Another big plus for commercial property investment is that in general the tenants pay the property taxes, insurance premiums, and other outgoings. Partially as a result of this, yield tends to be higher.
Consider owning ten million dollars of real estate. If this were all invested in residential properties, then you may own 40 or 50 separate homes. The management overhead would be significant. The same $10 million in commercial property could be spread over one or several properties with a similarly small number of tenants. The yields would probably be better, and the management overhead would be significantly reduced. The only question is, could you cope if you lost your main tenant?
There is no right or wrong answer to the question of whether you should buy residential or commercial. Each has its merits. You will know what is best for you. However, don't migrate to commercial property just because you think that is where the successful people are. Remember that buying one or two residential properties a year can turn you into a millionaire without some of the risks associated with commercial property investment.
Have another read of "The Millionaire Next Door" to remind yourself that most rich people have low profiles. And remember that for all the merits of commercial property, there have been some dramatic downturns of fortune for commercial property investors - individuals as well as companies. Meanwhile, holders of large parcels of residential property tended to not only survive but thrive.
There is however one advantage of commercial property which for me makes investing in commercial rather than residential property a no-brainer. A vacant residential property sells for about the same price as that same property tenanted. However, a vacant commercial property sells for much less than that same property tenanted. Consequently, if you can get an option on a vacant commercial property (to buy it at a price that reflects that it is vacant), secure a tenant, and then get financing on the basis of it being tenanted, the bank may willingly lend you more than your purchase price. This is a technique that I have used time and time again. I am surprised more people are not actively doing this. It enables you to buy real estate and put money in your pocket, with everyone's approval.
Successful investing!
Dolf de Roos
Dolf de Roos is the author 15 books on real estate including "Commercial Real Estate Investing" (John Wiley & Sons).


No comments:

Post a Comment